A Propaganda Claim That Just Refuses to Die: Ahmadinejad’s ‘Fraudulently’ Won Iranian Election

by Aug 1, 2013Foreign Policy0 comments

The problem with this is that not only is there no credible evidence that Ahmadinejad won through fraud, but all indications are that he won legitimately.

In an article on the election of Hassan Rouhani to the presidency of Iran, the New York Times throws in this line about the outgoing President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad:

Mr. Ahmadinejad came to power and was re-elected — fraudulently, most observers said…

This is true. Most observers were saying that Ahmadinejad stole the election. The problem with this is that not only is there no credible evidence that Ahmadinejad won through fraud, but all indications are that he won legitimately. I was one of the few pointing that out at the time. As I commented in May,

The claim that Ahmadinejad won Iran’s 2009 presidential by “fraud” persists despite all evidence suggesting that he was legitimately reelected.

I wrote that in response to a Foreign Affairs article repeating this propaganda claim. As I also wrote,

I wasn’t entirely alone in challenging the propaganda claim that Ahmadinejad stole the election. There were several others who refused to jump on the mainstream bandwagon and challenged the conventional narrative. Flynt Leverett and Hillary Mann Leverett wrote an excellent piece on the subject for Foreign Policy in which they cited two papers systematically debunking the claim of election fraud. The first paper was written by Reza Esfandiari and Yousef Bozorghehr in response to the Chatham House report and the second paper was written by Eric Brill. Both Esfandiari and Brill had seen my own work challenging the accepted narrative and contacted me to review that their papers before publication (I later reviewed another paper of Brill’s on the subject of the U.N., the IAEA, and Iran’s nuclear program). I blogged in June 2010 about how we were the exception to the rule and how the propaganda narrative continued to dominate despite no merely a complete lack of evidence for it, but despite all indications being that Ahmadinejad had legitimately won.

Needless to say, the prestigious journal Foreign Affairs still hasn’t gotten the memo.

And, equally needless to say, neither has the New York Times.

Did you find value in this content? If so and you have the means, please consider supporting my independent journalism.

About Jeremy R. Hammond

About Jeremy R. Hammond

I am an independent journalist, political analyst, publisher and editor of Foreign Policy Journal, book author, and writing coach.

My writings empower readers with the knowledge they need to see through state propaganda intended to manufacture their consent for criminal government policies.

By recognizing when we are being lied to and why, we can fight effectively for liberty, peace, and justice, in order to create a better world for ourselves, our children, and future generations of humanity.

Please join my growing community of readers!


My Books

Related Articles


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This